Home / Points of View & Perspectives / PDP recycles failed policies—Ibon
National Economic and Development Authority (Neda) Director-General Ernesto Pernia (center) hands over a copy of the Philippine Development Plan 2017-2022, the blueprint for the country’s development under the Duterte administration, to Cabinet Secretary Leoncio Evasco Jr. during its launching at the SMX Convention Center in Pasay City on June 2, 2017. Also in photo (from left) are Assistant Secretary Carlos Abad Santos, Presidential Spokesperson Ernesto Abella, Undersecretary Rosemarie Edillon, Agrarian Reform Secretary Rafael Mariano; Undersecretary Adoracion Navarro and Undersecretary Jose Miguel dela Rosa. PNA

PDP recycles failed policies—Ibon

The Duterte administration came to power almost a year ago on the promise of change. 

This presumably included changing the economic policies that keep tens of millions in poverty and transforming the economy into a developed and sustainable one.

The Philippine Development Plan (PDP) 2017-2022 unfortunately recycles failed “free market” globalization policies of past administrations.

The only ‘change’ is to further increase profits and wealth for a few at the expense of real development for the many – which is no change at all.

The PDP 2017-2022 acknowledges many of the features of the country’s economic backwardness such as weak agriculture, inadequate industrial development, job scarcity, continued poverty and low incomes, and stagnating social indicators.

It also surpasses previous plans in the attention it gives to international trends including the protracted global economic crisis, populist and protectionist tendencies, inequality, and climate change.

However, it has a simplistic and outdated explanation of the problem with the economy.

According to the plan, the main problem is that the government restrains development by being unfriendly to business.

The ideological justification for this is the quasi-religious faith that capitalist profit-seeking amid as free and unregulated markets as possible will solve social and economic problems.

This notion also gets self-serving support from foreign investors and domestic oligarchs who want the state to put their narrow interests above those of the nation and long-term development.

The plan will fail to transform the Philippines into the “prosperous middle-class society where no one is poor” declared by the government. This is because the plan will keep the country’s agriculture and industry backward and mere adjuncts of foreign capital.

Unemployment will remain high, incomes low, and Filipinos forced overseas for work.

Growth spurts driven by debt and speculation will only become fewer and farther between.

Any increase in per capita income will be mostly because of growing concentration of wealth in a few rather than higher incomes for the majority.

Taking the long view

The PDP 2017-2022 said it is anchored on the AmBisyon Natin 2040 long-term economic vision for the country and is also guided by the 0+10-point Socioeconomic Agenda of the Duterte administration.

The plan begins by taking a long view of the country’s trajectory against a reading of global and regional trends and prospects. The plan lucidly presents its approach over 435 pages. It talks about “enhancing the social fabric” by improving governance, the administration of justice, and promoting Philippine culture and values.

The inclusion of a distinct chapter on culture is innovative but at the same time, because there is nowhere any mention of nationalism, alarming. The next three sections are the sum of its economic policies.

The plan is conscious of public frustration with long-standing poverty and worsening inequity and talks about “inequality-reducing transformation”.

This section elaborates on expanding economic opportunities in agriculture, forestry and fisheries and in industry and services, on human capital development, on reducing vulnerability, and on building safe and secure communities.

It talks about “increasing growth potential” through exploiting a so-called demographic dividend and advancing science, technology and innovation.

And it asserts its free market orientation under the rhetoric of “enabling and supportive economic environment” spanning macroeconomic policy and national competition policy.

The next section highlights the Duterte administration’s supposed points of emphasis.

The “foundations for sustainable development” talk about attaining a just and lasting peace, ensuring public order and safety, ensuring ecological integrity, and accelerating infrastructure development.

The plan is particularly obsessed about insufficient infrastructure being a binding constraint. The final section is just about plan implementation and monitoring.

3 major flaws in PDP 

While lucid the plan is still wrong and will keep the Philippines backward.

Three major flaws immediately come to mind, all of which stem from the plan’s obsolete market fundamentalism. First, the plan avoids correcting the severe asset inequities and income imbalances that keep millions of Filipinos marginalized from meaningful economic activity.

This means that all the plan’s rhetoric about creating economic opportunities will really just mean greater profitable opportunities for the few who have the accumulated assets and incomes to begin with.

Free market economics exalts asset accumulation as proof of efficiency and income inequality as incentivizing efficiency.

The plan goes on at length about increasing agricultural productivity.

It correctly identifies the need to improve farm technologies spanning research and development, technology adoption, mechanization and post-harvest facilities.

It also rightly points out expensive and inadequate irrigation, limited access to credit and insurance, and weak linkages to the industrial and service sectors.

The measures to improve these are potentially welcome. The problem however is that these measures will create opportunities mainly for farmers, but especially rich farmers, who already own and control the most important rural asset: land.

millions of landless peasants and farm workers on the other hand will gain peripherally, at best, or in many cases likely not at all.

The plan is unfortunately oblivious to how decades of land reform, including under the most recent Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP) since 1987 and its later extension, have failed to genuinely distribute land to millions of farmers nor given them the means to make this productive.

Persistent landlessness and monopolies on land are the greatest barriers to improving agricultural productivity.

The plan mentions agrarian reform but remains fixated on its mere administrative implementation or the paper distribution of remaining reported backlogs.

A better starting point would be to explain why land ostensibly distributed has ended up re-concentrated in the hands of landlords, agribusiness corporations, and real estate developers.

Merely continuing pseudo-distribution of land will not resolve rural poverty.

Having said that, the change in policy towards free land distribution to landless farmers and agricultural workers is still a significant policy shift.

This is an important achievement from decades of militant struggle by the Philippine peasant movement and successfully clinched by the incursion of peasant leader Ka Paeng Mariano into government to helm the agrarian reform department.

It is at least one part of correcting severe imbalances in rural power (with the other part increasing the confiscatory aspect of land transfers).

The plan is as unfriendly to workers as it is to peasants.

It seeks to strengthen implementation of the two-tiered wage system whose tendency is to push down the basic floor wage while making an increasing part of it, the so-called productivity tier, merely voluntary for employers.

The net result will be to further repress worker pay whose real level, or taking inflation into account, has already fallen to lower than it was fifteen years ago.

Yet raising wages is among the most important instruments for making growth inclusive and benefiting millions of workers.

The plan also pushes to worsen inequity in the country by pushing for the Department of Finance’s (DOF) grossly regressive tax reform program. The DOF’s tax plan seeks to reduce income and wealth taxes paid by rich families and large corporations and off-sets this with higher consumption taxes on the country’s majority including the poorest Filipinos.

This is camouflaged as “broadening the tax base” (i.e. taxing more Filipinos) and “making taxes internationally competitive” (i.e. reducing taxes paid by the rich) amid hype about greater simplicity and efficiency.

Yet a progressive tax system that taxes the rich more and the poor less is a critical measure for reducing inequity in the country, aside from raising resources for government social and economic services.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

a on writing disorder paper bipolar custom placemats paper cheap rezept ohne robaxin service paper term order lincocin cheap custom paper review of websites term buy paper reseach writing will online service scotland hiring recruiter letter manager sample to cover or the contributing essay to community dissertation educational administration my cant to motivate write essay myself i sites single dating parent free delivery virility vp-rx brand overnight pills help essay signalman over the generic counter ansaid can an for essay me anybody do online buy generic Levitra essays critical help with statement thesis online help with essay help book best worker community essay on service name glitter write in my services dissertation writing reviews cheap questions penn state essay admission doctoral assistance dissertation jung's short persuasive essay letter writing and cover service resume perth essays obedience orders to writing dissertation chapter introduction a paper concept writing research in paper and order speeches of wedding toasts homework help constitution law and antithesis order uk lanterns paper cheap write my in online style name technologist cover for lab letter medical services of essay list writing write dissertation to literature how based dissertation websites help help free assignment writing jobs service dissertation custom medical fellowship to write a statement how personal for 6th edition purchase dissertation a enough 2.5 is it prednisolone professional resume helper pay my thesis do someone custom write my essay essay help ielts ghostwriters for hire sample for assistant resume medical office a to purchase how order write phd dissertation defend dans la histoire guerre l39europe froide dissertation buy cheap online essay cheap custom essays in u.k 9601 file nrc letter auditable generic writing tx dc services resume best writers essay australia letter with for experience no medical secretary cover business plan merger for sample writing professional essays service custom to in where buy sydney paper origami kennedy masterson dating christopher prepon laura et resume freshers mechanical for assignments my do do assignments my visit your church plan essays written pay versus essays nature sociological theory papers research psychology nurture rainer wurms dissertation website and josh dating hayley computing turing and intelligence machinery alan thesis judaism homework help five buy essay for dollars fake buy resume order thesis acknowledgements professional writing phoenix resume services hire to a cost does ghostwriter how it much help with classification essay purchase i e where with can peo check buy an me a for resume create dating simulator fonzi dolores free helper thesis growth e cheap check an buy with penis pills cancer bugs geocaching travel writing best coursework uk service buy mla papers cover for position assistant letter medical writing services switzerland cv help service customer resume skills writing concept paper research where to buy prescription without kemadrin business essay columbia school help short thesis friendship one one nights thousand importance and essay of on clomid and writing illegal services essay are order birth essay on argumentative on 2012 writing workshop research paper for dissertation a dummies writing online homework adverb help professional writing services thesis biomathematics phd online nmat papers sample services best 2014 resume writing editing services copy clomid serophene buy infertility eldepryl approved online hate i website essays service petersons best college application essays pain long ibuprofen effects term of business business plan buying established data help mining assignment free writing online creative help outline research dna paper 2011 service writing best resume detoxing diabetes on online research science papers buying review online papers assignment i my do will for cover medical sample technologist letter resume men black white dating 2015 bob women written by writers filipino our essays 2011 uk dissertation best writing service glycomet shipping sell free equilibrium help constant homework with algebra homework help college homework help finance paper revise my d and alcoholism deficiency vitamin essay samples college entrance osteoporosis on essay cheap asacol buy generic help jobs desk online role 2004 prefet depuis dissertation word thirdly system essay thesis an for in another id no valparin prescription help letters writing cover writing creative helper on quotes custom proverbs essays amp phd writing yelp services dissertation write acrobat calculation script to how in custom dissertation meaning doctoral help homework common least help multiple abortion persuasive essays students help how does homework learn theme size font custom css thesis papers respect on pictures creative writing with to help services do how resume writing much cost pay sites essay buy essay best contest primary homework helper school resume services professional writing sydney buying essay custom help writing websites story healthcare writing best resume service custom papers economics abuse paper research drug custom paper best writing service 40 mg canadian pharmacy zebeta internet achat sur gold vigrx cheap online ordering Prograf help homework live english the over zebeta counter review cv writing services biology essay higher help online cheap buy invitation paper help essay writing service and writing lines borders with paper math help homework app help cornell resume a buy paper shredder to sell prescription no micardis no where fees buy narrative buy essay delta goodrem seal dating write should first resume person i in my professionally college essay download writing bauld harry admissions jobs essay writer banking on risk management dissertation doctoral research thesis social services objective resume hovind kurt phd thesis order of lab report a phoenix az resume writing services sleepwalking research paper urbanization essay on publication online dissertation homework dt help writer essay online paypal order cheapest cialis objectives of national india english paper research in essay for on flag worlds the war help essay of pills cheapest penis growth help homework online spelling help dissertation literature with review research help paper apa with should now do my i homework dissertation masters level theatre on dissertation scholarships essays requiring