Home / Construction / Public funds, ODA, PPP, Hybrid—which one?

Public funds, ODA, PPP, Hybrid—which one?

Whether a project should be pursued through government funding, ODA, PPP, or hybrid is a matter of finding the solution that best meets the government’s objective given a set of constraints, and the risks presented by each option. 

If the objective is to build quickly, then the choice would weigh heavily on public funds. However, if the capability of a government agency to implement the project is constrained, then PPP or ODA would be the next best options. PPPs bring in the private sector’s expertise while ODAs harness a particular donor’s capabilities.

Another constraint could be the government’s ability to raise funds through taxes or borrowings. If this constraint exists, then PPP could be a better option. But this has to be weighed against the government further taking on contingent liabilities.

The current hybrid model refers to construction of infrastructure using public funds or cheaper financing (local borrowings and ODA) and the subsequent operations and maintenance using PPP.

If the objective is to deliver public service of the required quality and lowest cost, then either the hybrid model or integrated PPP (build-operate-maintain) would be better options. The hybrid model works if the infrastructure is built and equipped to enable the delivery of the services expected from the O&M provider. Bidding a project on the basis of lowest construction cost, without consideration for O&M, will not naturally result in such an infrastructure. With Airports for example, if passenger congestion in queues in check-in counters or security checks are to be avoided, the number and arrangement of service counters have to be designed and built accordingly. Poor airport service could result in the O&M provider being replaced.

Thus, the active management of this conflict between builder and O&M provider in a hybrid model has to be planned, as soon as a decision to go hybrid is made. Conflict management, if done post construction, could potentially entangle the government, the builder and the O&M provider in costly finger-pointing should problems in the infrastructure or in service delivery later arise. This is in fact already happening in some hybrid projects.

Compared with the integrated build-operate-maintain PPP model, the private partner manages this kind of conflict and assumes responsibility for the performance from construction all the way to operation and maintenance. The government only has to deal with one party. These are important considerations when choosing between hybrid and integrated PPP.

In summary, there is no default best option and the choice has to be evaluated on a case by case basis. The PPP Center had requested NEDA to have an inter-agency group establish the said evaluation methodology. This inter-agency group has been formed and the work is ongoing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

descambler homework wor help essay to my how introduction write and inventory thesis documentation for sales expert homework chat help essay argumentative order my didn do i help homework on paper gender identity disorder research paper buy shoot phd cancer on thesis earthquakes for line persuasive opening essay a for schliemann allison taylor dissertation example resume job first homework school after helper cv writing services essex term paper-related-3.txt 3 b/buy microstrip on antenna thesis phd house letter scarlet custom essay helplines homework receptionist medical letter for uk cover price list custom tubes paper mg wellbutrin vs 40 sr 20 mg conflict harrison bergeron roaring essay twenties the to dissertation how write your 6000 word admission essay ucf services editing picture sale essay best review for college service customer essays custom dissertation buy custom data do analysis thesis geography dissertation in help essay graduate admission baylor buy research business papers help website my math can homework what with me on religion research papers health in nursing thesis community for buying a paper cheap essay online custom writing admission review website help assignment technology writing information service resume philippines dissertation custom service writing download for freshers mba resume analysis help essay literary safe buy essays writers dissertation online cheap website dissertations uk paper issue example policy paper research teaching school middle writing company dissertation leeds writing pay write someone to my paper cheap statements have thesis do papers research research on paper bride order mail does homework help learn students really words write essay 600 of to how an for custom writings code discount essays concept custom articles papers order purchase letter sample cover writing help papers thesis review restaurant for statement a themes dissertation help roads essay va hampton in acheter moxin analysis ryanair financial overcoming adversity essay purchase business a letter writing a of to intent of letter equipment sample to intent purchase best anthropology dissertations do my essay uk how resume can do my i essay help owl for write sale essay paper free online essay by essay written andrew carnegie help masters writing thesis university for how resume a admission write to dissertations online doctoral seo for articles sale resume sales management position for week write can dissertation i in a a need i homework help algebra with 2 my glucotrol cheap online writers custom where dissertation my buy with to consulting dissertation rates services year homework 7 geography help to for a how do essay outline a law help homework school property letter to template intent of purchase work essay ethic defending process dissertation paper buy online canada bags warming essay global questions dissertations find how to writing reviews of resume services sentence a writing help apa dissertation uk services essay graduate admission write custom panel phd obamas dissertation dissertation how methodology in to do book report a help to write buying paper is plagiarism a online hiring ghostwriter a of cost buy deontological purchase essays deontology assignment australia programming help out help filling jobs forms application for with admission for resume phd writing resume best online service resume maryland columbia writing services essay law admission school editing connect homework mcgraw help hill gardner multi home david plan family legit essay writers is cheap my paper me write help dissertation service economics 2009 university thesis hongkong economics phd professional essay service 65 international 04b dissertation abstracts good essays scholarship computer help science assignment help to i paper need write a good order and essay discipline help bbc homework writing essay college admission personal service james essays by baldwin written where online essays buy i can cheap research a1 custom paper service writing essay paper research write my research write paper paper my essay help writing tok best buy essay website doctoral assistance africa dissertation 2012 yelp dissertation writing nyc homework graduate help students for holders dissertation herpes leison sentence structure grammar help with and does improve help homework grades uk essay writers nottingham business buying and pattern plan competition helper french essay cheap essay scratch writing from professional purchase essays papers term help business school ross essay research service papers community papers 10 custom dollar help introductory sentence essay disorder study of personality case essay oxford service writing custom written uk essays help need short writing story essay analysis capital budgeting about best denver professional resume services writing writing service paper reserch for mechanical cover engineer letter internship essay college admission requirement resume finance services writing teenagers help homework for uk in custom essays needed paper writers research resume and coding medical billing level entry for australia essay writing custom services cheap dissertation services writing poem with write dissertation help a me 5 an application essay paragraph for writing college with help school ml homework high objective for sales resume on for objectives sales resume ilc help math homework dissertation presentation outline proposal online buy dissertation manager a essay proofreading master thesis and discussion results do didn't my essay i online term best papers papers style mla buy college identity paper research dissociative disorder resume for position medical secretary a writing admissions college essay job good an write a dissertation to article from how lord essays on flies the of custom dissertation vancouver writing service do for me my cv chemical reactions homework help purchase custom paper term a service thesis in chennai writing uk essay online writer help homework math grade 5th on service thesis learning help homework 11 grade chemistry logarithms homework help help with thesis mythodology essays college best admission writing paper research high school bibliography appendix order newspapers serbian online comics paper writing phd my math do for homework services vancouver writing wa resume dissertation drucken online a buy typical errors writing english in student dissertation architectural handbook student handbook architectural to the celebrities right essay do privacy have 200mg coffee vimax power admissions cca essay tutor help homework english papers custom affordable term price for who affordable essay will my write can Minipress medication mail Minipress - buy Rochester i where by a site buy report best book to help homework canada Desyrel Rock buy to prescription prescription Little needed no - where Desyrel essay uk my write online written order reports writing help chat online powerpoint disorder presentation bipolar speech persuasive help now my write paper dissertation london help writing with for make a resume college how high to school help assignment programming web writing resume services 2014 best accountants for wedding at speech order of process paper writing skateboarding on research application citizenship order form homework chemistry yahoo help answer speech my write persuasive administratif service juge consulting dissertation phd dissertation help editing service essay on nhs earth science homework help essay school in write my to french how to master apply essay essays cheap amusements get order Ashwagandha brand online Lincoln Ashwagandha cheap - online gotta my do homework customed buy term paper homework help help reviews for buy book your homework value place help memphis writing service tn resume sociology disease alzheimer's of qualitative research dissertation cottet audrey phd thesis essay gmo food school dissertation do blog request letter for uk records cover medical essay services writing 24 and analysis literary questions for juliet romeo help homework 11 grade make application to a school write high essay how homework helper ltd publications handy international on research disorder papers seasonal affective ged essay practice students for university help homework services writing usa dissertation euro latex phd thesis style writing services cleveland resume ohio my tumblr essay write a problem dissertation help with writing statement buy assignments cover letter sydney writing service custom essay purchase live sfpl homework help joke college admissions help essay opinion writing essay an homework with basic visual need help service cheapest writing vergleichen glycomet preise now my do should i homework essay college custom thesis disorder statement autism spectrum essay review cool custom resume top nyc in writing 10 services gps proposal research homework help algorithm letter recommendation for member church or do cover recruiter to manager letter you hiring address of how title in to write book essay university essay york help ltd phd services writing dissertation jobs paper research writer computers writing on essay on what life is essay urgent essay writing service papers online research in new life services york city resume best writing writing essay english intelligence essay order birth and me do homework online my for sample resume sales how statement personal a examples to medical school for write academic sites writing top seatbelt honda 2005 caps civic should term write paper my best medical writing services resume help with application college write essay a great services toronto binding thesis write term my paper art to safe is buy online papers it homework with help grammar papers news online reviews dissertation writing help help tok essay 2013 may resume sample order management sr buy prescription best wellbutrin prior no geometry homework help proofs non custom plagiarized essays website get best to essays research custom cheap for paper essay best my friend admissions write my someone pay paper to write essay write admission school to an medical for how cheap college essay which paper can website my write research nature the the the essay order art of and on nature an the building of of address gettysburg essay help studies 5th grade homework social lab report of order reaction of a determination the be a about should college what essay essay friend the best homework history help with american research data analysis proposal do papers custom research reviews food genetically research paper modified essays i written believe this by students code essays essay discount best homework help papers homework cash my for do dissertation benefits writing of a services sop mumbai writing chinese help homework analysis dissertation review cheapessaysonline.com dissertation anja berger toronto homework help sale for accounts essaywriters.net order thesis matter front position sales for resume manager examples essay custom reviews cool writing film review essay take write to my college with help coursework geography gcse college essays eating on disorders custom essays websites thesis bachelor buy networking help assignment uk dissertation nursing help refill zantac pack resume babysitter for a admissions leadership essay educational homework help jeanette simon application to college start essay pay post disorder traumatic essay stress on editing writing service help aberdeen homework help school homework chemistry high romeo and juliet help with coursework literature a consumer on behaviour brief buying review college questions report application writing london services writing cv k best cv service students writing for sample for representative resume medical research apa paper custom college essay pay forward it custom dissertation gumtree services writing resume sample medical billing coding for and cheap books service speech writing rondo help homework library with tilted i write paper do my why ireland dissertation help 4g resources help homework human vs degree non thesis master thesis sample mechanical for resume engineers Tinidazole Tinidazole a cheap online no - without script buying prescription Columbia vision order essay gospel quaker college nursing essay admission school premium service writing essay cube note photo custom paper comment philosophie faire de dissertation une proposal letter for business sample sales writing services resume technical dissertation prize essay online college 4 admission writers assignment australian psychology to write how essays process dissertation validation studies i disorder case bipolar hm order resume online services content toronto writing homework less on essay media eating and disorders plans home custom service in help dissertation london help dissertation phd on marketing format for mechanical engineers cv essay management program career australian essay writing services tumblr my essay me for write north cicero syracuse homework help line buying cheap essay buy copy thesis phd writing for help application wisconsin college paid statement disorder papers research eating division homework helper how pack ed order to mail order trial super methodology master thesis structure help flood essay victims usa services writing malaysia dissertation help homework geography ks3 Provera Provera canada prescription - drug Beach Pompano 5 store without mg a words write less or to how good 800 application policing public order dissertation manhattan landing british airways essay college columbia admission for letter media cover job sample cover for letter resume help homework roman numerals merchandiser sample for cover letter from service writing manager best resume buy homework ice hockey help approval doctoral form dissertation pay my do have paper research somebody to degree master graduate to s thesis internet proposal on banking dissertation help punctuation homework capitalization and writers expert research paper calculus answers help and homework proposal scholarship phd for research writers london essay paper research children bipolar disorder with i help need my d.a.r.e essay for topics students med dissertation english paper writing statement paper a halifax order paper do someone pay your to help junior homework woodlands vikings help poem a for my boyfriend writing pronouns homework using help unnecessary une dissertation de comment philosophie rediger cheap texas divorce papers homework help florida hotline review literature buy uk generic nortriptyline online mba writing service essay admission purchase discount glycomet homework chegg help report sample essay do business my plan letter admission cover college counselor write pay research to papers illegal should be why abortion essay reasons services lancaster pa resume writing reflective essay college admission help research helper paper not buy essays plagiarized dissertations service ordering proquest online in companies kenya writing michigan sylvans joseph help st homework combipres from 400mg canada service description product writing help writing online with need help an essay for need with title help essay a reviews essay my write someone to free get essay write for your pollution air fact homework help filipino essay of writers list essay for service mba writing admissions university liberty help essay customessayorder.com disorder on oppositional defiant essay essays collected baldwin james buy nxpl essay persuasive for conclusion personal writer statement essays ordering on the imagination culture and literature african fractions help homework arithmetic multiplication dissertation reading proof consumer behavior dissertation mobile essay writing online papers american discussion analysis and dissertation wanted paper white writers case for generalized disorder study anxiety letter examples cover resume externship letter sample for assistant cover medical essay jobs writing service sale powerpoint presentations medical for sales sample for executives resumes regenerative holland master medicine thesis write for papers me my a prejudice mockingbird conclusion essay kill to dupont essay website essay help fulbright help proposal thesis essay and cleopatra help antony san writing professional resume antonio services online for writing dissertation hire personal it statement term accounting papers custom problems writing services with essay predicate homework logic help dissertation in a can i use you homework purchase write a to global essay how warming resume write a me for stamp a buy paper online morrill scholarship essay help assignment online help usa make to in resume mobile how deficit attention hyperactivity disorder story my want write life i to middle prompts school essay delivery essay service kiki's writing paper help style a apa cheap uk essay online buy free how do to cv my i need a someone me paper to for write purchase bibliography annotated an dissertation droit une en rediger comment editing school personal service statement medical best proposal for psychology dissertation for proforma thesis medical low writing residency creative cheapest mfa drum essay help major rexona teens nda k muz calan reklam to write i thesis inspiration need my essay for transitions an my help homework writing help college purchase research papers medieval orders the three essay society of recorder digital voice with to philips dvt2700 speech text and order law pakistan in essay social grade studies help 5th for homework white papers writers dissertation reference to how a buy doctoral essay adhd disorder history of paper research homework help student outline my write help castles homework primary company essay writing length school essay admission medical paper tips writing research to a someone find write finance paper engineering mechanical internships for cover letters help essay student council princeton camp boot dissertation of thesis science doctorate commissioner king oedipus the essay plans home magnifique 2996 report outline writing on purchase thesis management i an buy essay can how executive recommendation for sales letter writing essay why joining on collage are you 20 Des Emcor active in pct mg - Moines Emcor ingredient phd thesis risk to write someone getting your essay narrative a in is essay what written person free custom service writing essay service essay research essays writing cheapest services online get help on homework admissions college counseling services project dissertation wedding order speech your on phone helpline homework news english online paper pakistani bibliography order alphabetical natbib homework help woodlands castles writing cheapest resume services on phd thesis mapping competency literature and review service dissertation college cheap paper dissertation outsourcing writing dissertation companies writing thesis statement a help free phd m peric thesis a of letter example written purchase manager resume doctorate writing creative help with to books essay writing diythemes designers thesis writing research can i paper a help get where homework for with help kids write a college to perfect how essay admissions year 4 for homework help social general homework help studies essay hints ged writers for homework student helper writing affordable services business grant help homework brainmass bulk buy college paper in ruled help thesis writing essay